The heroes flight to the first Post-Crisis crossover

Legends (1986) Reading Order: The First Post-Crisis Crossover

ByBobo
Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

In 1986, DC Comics was fresh off the success of Crisis on Infinite Earths. It was a new era with a rebooted universe. After that, the question was: What next? The answer seems to have been “another crossover event.”

Before we got the Legends we know today, there was “Crisis of the Soul.” This scrapped 12-issue project was designed to show a world turning on its heroes through spiritual corruption. Though canceled after months of development, some of his ideas survived. In August 1986, editor Mike Gold and a star-studded creative team launched Legends. It wasn’t a sequel to Crisis, but an “introduction” to the modern DC Universe.

  1. Historical Context
  2. Collecting Legends in 2026
  3. Full Reading Order

1. Opening Up the DCU: Reintroducing the Heroes

Plotted by John Ostrander, scripted by Len Wein, penciled by John Byrne, and inked by Karl Kesel, Legends saw Darkseid attacking Earth by using an original tactic: destroying their status as living legends, presenting them as the problem, not the solution. He sent agents to manipulate public opinion, leading people to reject those they swore to protect.

Reading the event today, the plot feels a bit flimsy, and the crossover in itself has to push hard to keep up with it. I found Legends to be very optional, except for two things: if you are reading the Justice League Detroit era and want the conclusion, and if you are interested in the Suicide Squad. And even then, most of the event is skippable.

Key Historical Story Elements:

  • The Modern Suicide Squad: This event is the first appearance of the John Ostrander-style Task Force X.
  • The End of a Justice League: The old Justice League comes and goes, making space for Keith Giffen and J. M. DeMatteis’ relaunch, the Justice League International.
  • Wonder Woman Meets the Heroes: George Pérez’s run on Wonder Woman started to be published only two months before Legends #6, in which Diana makes her first appearance outside of her title, meeting the other heroes.
  • Captain Marvel’s Introduction: Billy Batson was reintroduced in the DCU during the event, but played a more significant part in the story. The following year, his new origin story was published in Shazam!: The New Beginning by Dann and Roy Thomas, and artist Tom Mandrake

2. Finding the Legends event in 2026

For a long time, DC Comics had only made available a trade paperback published in 2016 to celebrate the 30th anniversary of the Legends event that collected the 6 main issues.

In 2026, in time for the 40th anniversary, the new massive hardcover edition collects this time the main eventwith all the tie-ins.

  • Legends 30th Anniversary Edition – Collects Legends #1-6.
  • Legends 30th Anniversary – Digital Edition – Collects Legends #1-6.
  • Legends Omnibus – Collects Legends #1-6, Batman #401, Detective Comics #568, Green Lantern Corps #207, Cosmic Boy #1-4, Justice League of America #258-261, Secret Origins #10 and #14, The Fury of Firestorm #55-56 and #58-59, Blue Beetle #9-10, The Warlord #114-115, Superman #3, Adventures of Superman #426, and Action Comics #586

3. The Complete Legends Reading Order

There are three ways to read Legends. The first is to stick with the 6-issue miniseries. The second is to go through the 28+ issues published under the Legends banner. The third is to read the mini and only the tie-ins connected to the characters you are interested in.

The following reading guide to the Legends crossover will help you select the issues you want to read:

Legends #1 (1987) cover by John Byrne
Superman (Vol. 2) #3 cover by John Byrne
Secret Origins (Vol. 2) #14 Cover by Luke McDonnell

The Prologue

  • Batman #401: The first post-crisis Batman story ft. Magpie (see Man of Steel #3) and G. Gordon Godfrey, who is the man arguing for a ban on superheroes.
  • Detective Comics #568: Batman vs. the Penguin. Only the last page referenced the growing anti-hero sentiment and Godfrey.
  • Legends #1: The official beginning of the event.
  • Green Lantern Corps #207: Guy Gardner’s back on Earth. A prelude to his appearance in Legends #2.

Fun fact: The “G. Gordon Godfrey” name is a reference to G. Gordon Liddy, one of the co-conspirators in the Watergate scandal.

The Rising Tension

  • Legends #2: The tension rises
  • Cosmic Boy #1: What happened to Legion of Super-Heroes’s Cosmic Boy directly after the events of Legends #2.
  • Justice League of America #258: The JLA is disbanded. It’s the beginning of the end. Part 1/4.
  • Secret Origins (Vol. 2) #10: Four possible origins of the Phantom Stranger. Only one “Footsteps” will be referenced in later books.
  • Firestorm (Vol. 2) #55: What happened to Firestorm directly after the events of Legends #2.
  • Booster Gold #13: Not officially labeled as part of the event, it is set at this point and follows Booster while recovering from a battle.
  • Legends #3: Enter The Suicide Squad.

The World at War

  • Cosmic Boy #2: The continued adventures of Cosmic Boy and Night Girl as public opinion of the heroes turns sour and violent.
  • Justice League of America #259: Someone is after the leaguers. Part 2/4.
  • Firestorm (Vol. 2) #56: In Pittsburgh, Godfrey’s acolyte creates chaos, but Firestorm fights inner conflict.
  • Blue Beetle (Vol. 6) #9: Back in Chicago, BB is having office problems. Introduces the Chronos story that concludes in Legends #4.
  • Legends #4: The situation descends into chaos.
  • Warlord #114: Follow-up to what happened after Darkseid sent his assistant DeSaad to Skartaris to destroy the legend of Warlord.
  • Cosmic Boy #3: Cosmic Boy and Night Girl can’t go back to their time and have to fix their Time Bubble.
  • Justice League of America #260: J’onn J’onzz tries to save the Leaguers. Part 3/4.
  • Blue Beetle (Vol. 6) #10: Following Legends #4, BB tracks the Time-Thief.
  • Warlord #115: The real Warlord learns what happened and goes after DeSaad.

Note: This reading order follows the official one, but if you prefer, you can read all the Justice League of America comics consecutively. Idem for the Warlord and Cosmic Boy issues. It doesn’t affect the overall story.

The Superman “Apokolips” Trilogy

The next three Superman tie-ins form a complete storyline. Darkseid kidnapped Clark Kent, bringing him to Apokolips, where he’ll try to help the little people.

  • Superman (Vol. 2) #3
  • Adventures of Superman #426
  • Action Comics #586

The Grand Finale

  • Legends #5: G. Gordon Godfrey’s rhetoric reaches a new level.
  • Cosmic Boy #4: The end of the 4-issue miniseries. Can be read directly after CB #3.
  • Justice League of America #261: Part 4/4. The end of the Detroit era of the JLA.
  • Legends #6: The Final confrontation and the formation of the new Justice League.
  • Secret Origins (Vol. 2) #14: The Secret Origin of the Suicide Squad.

After the Legends: Where to Go Next?

While the events saw the conclusion of Volume 1 of Justice League of America, Legends wasn’t an ending, but a launchpad. Here is a quick map to follow what came after:

  • Cosmic Boy and Night Girl’s story continues in the pages of Legion of Super-Heroes #36.
  • Justice League of America is dead. Long live the Justice League International.
  • Batman started his Modern Age run with the first two issues of the event.
  • Superman continues his reinvention under John Byrne’s direction
  • Captain Marvel is back in Shazam!: The New Beginning.
  • The Suicide Squad members are back in their own series by John Ostrander.
  • Wonder Woman had only begun her Modern Age renaissance with the freshly launched reboot (Volume 2).
  • The Flash (aka Wally West) runs in a new solo title, The Flash (Volume 2), right after Legends.
  • Blue Beetle (Vol. 6) continues for over 10 more issues. He’ll join the JLI with Booster Gold.
  • Warlord continues up to issue #133.
  • Firestorm had barely reached the halfway mark of its volume. It continued for years.
  • The fate of Glorious Godfrey is revealed in Suicide Squad #3.

The Case Continues: The Road to Millennium

The resolution of the Legends conflict brought a brief moment of stability to the DC Universe, but it also left the world’s heroes exposed. As the new Justice League found its footing and the “Modern Age” of the Man of Steel began, a far older threat was preparing to strike from within.

The paranoia established by G. Gordon Godfrey was merely a prelude to the Manhunter conspiracy. Having spent centuries embedding sleeper agents into the lives of Clark Kent, Wally West, and the Guardians of the Universe, the Manhunters were finally ready to activate their global network.

[Continue the history: The Millennium (1988) Reading Order]

More Files from the Casebook

  • |

    Batman: Battle for the Cowl Reading Order: Looking For a New Batman

    ByBobo
    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    In 2009, following the psychological warfare of Batman R.I.P. and the cosmic sacrifice of Final Crisis, Gotham City woke up to its ultimate nightmare: a world without Batman. Battle for the Cowl deals with the Dark Knight’s succession.

    Written and illustrated by Tony S. Daniel, this three-issue limited series focuses on what would happen when Batman, as a symbol more than a superhero, were to vanished from Gotham City. With the tie-ins, the story examines what happens in such a case, leaving a vacuum that both the underworld and the Bat-Family scramble to fill. This is a key event as it sets up the next era of Batman.

    Read More “Batman: Battle for the Cowl Reading Order: Looking For a New Batman”
  • |

    Final Crisis Reading Order: The Day Evil Won (2008)

    ByBobo
    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    With Batman R.I.P., Grant Morrison not only wrote the psychological destruction of the Dark Knight, but also paved the way for a new threat menacing the whole DC Multiverse, one that went beyond physical conquest. Final Crisis is the story of the “God of Evil,” Darkseid, finally discovering the Anti-Life Equation and using it to enslave the consciousness of the human race.

    This isn’t a war fought only in the streets, it’s a war fought for the soul of reality. As the “New Gods” of Apokolips fall to Earth and inhabit human hosts, the sky turns red, time begins to collapse, and the heroes of the DC Universe are forced into a final stand against a darkness that has already won.

    Read More “Final Crisis Reading Order: The Day Evil Won (2008)”
  • |

    Countdown to Final Crisis Reading Order: The Year the Multiverse Fractured

    ByBobo
    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    Published between 2007 and 2008 by DC Comics, Countdown to Final Crisis was designed as the weekly lead-in to Final Crisis, following in the publishing model established by 52. Running for 51 issues, the series attempted to lay the groundwork for the next major crisis in the DC Universe while following multiple parallel storylines involving cosmic threats, multiversal instability, and several major DC characters.

    Things didn’t turn out as well as with 52. It was a massive editorial blunder. As Grant Morrison explained it at the time: “Final Crisis was partly-written and broken down into rough issue-by-issue plots before Countdown was even conceived, let alone written.” But despite that, the writing led by Paul Dini seems to lack enough details to not contradict what would eventually happen in Final Crisis. As a result, plotlines in Countdown had diverged so much that continuity between the two publishing initiatives became partly nonsensical. Some elements complement Final Crisis and add a greater understanding of the end story, but most do the opposite. Characters who died end up alive (and are killed again), and whole storylines are redone in Final Crisis, and the overall tone doesn’t fit. If you add to that Death of the New Gods by Jim Starlin, to which Countdown began to respond before veering away from it, the confusion became maddening.

    Today, Countdown to Final Crisis is a complicated affair to deal with for readers. If you are a completist, you can’t skip it. Idem if you are trying to follow some secondary characters. Ultimately, this is widely considered to be non-canonical.

    Read More “Countdown to Final Crisis Reading Order: The Year the Multiverse Fractured”

  • Is John Byrne’s Superman Still Good? A 2026 Retrospective Review

    ByBobo
    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    In 1986, John Byrne undertook the challenging project of reimagining Superman as a relatable contemporary figure. This involved making some controversial decisions. He abandoned the optimism of the Silver Age in favour of a more psychologically grounded interpretation, shaped by the cultural logic of the 1980s. It was criticized by some for being Superman for adults. Four decades later, does it still resonate, or was it purely a product of its time?

    While later interpretations have emphasized Superman as a near-mythical ‘space god’, Byrne’s work is the most notable ‘human-first’ reimagining of the character. It established the modern Lex Luthor and a proactive, credible Lois Lane, but it also led to a Superman who violated his own moral code in a conclusion that remains controversial. Whether regarded as a necessary modernization or a fundamental misreading of the character, Byrne’s influence continues to shape virtually every screen adaptation of Superman.

    Although I have read DC Comics for decades, I was never particularly interested in Superman. To broaden my understanding of the character, I approached this landmark series from a contemporary perspective. So, in this review, we’re looking past the nostalgia.

    Read More “Is John Byrne’s Superman Still Good? A 2026 Retrospective Review”

  • The Man of Tomorrow, Reborn: A Deep Dive into John Byrne’s Superman (1986-1988)

    ByBobo
    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    In the mid-1980s, Superman was in trouble. Decades of ‘Silver Age’ excess, such as super-dogs, pocket dimensions, and limitless powers, had made the Man of Steel feel both invincible and rather out of touch with the times. Following the universe-shaking ‘Crisis on Infinite Earths’, DC Comics did the unthinkable and recruited Marvel superstar John Byrne to rewrite Superman’s mythology.

    The result was a fundamental shift in perception that still influences how we view Clark Kent today. Whether you are an avid collector or a new reader exploring these issues in digital archives, Byrne’s work remains the definitive ‘modern’ starting point.

    Read More “The Man of Tomorrow, Reborn: A Deep Dive into John Byrne’s Superman (1986-1988)”

  • The Ultimate John Byrne Superman Reading Order (1986-1988)

    ByBobo
    Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases (Affiliate Disclosure). Thanks!

    John Byrne’s run on Superman wasn’t just limited to one book. It was a “Triangle Era” precursor where stories flowed between Superman, Action Comics, and Adventures of Superman (written by Marv Wolfman, but essential for context).

    Here is the ultimate contextual reading order.

    Read More “The Ultimate John Byrne Superman Reading Order (1986-1988)”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *